Episode 13 - Lights Out

What do airports, water treatment facilities, gas stations, and espresso machines all have in common? A dependence on a reliable and stable network of power generation and distribution. In America, and around the world, our electrical grids are aged, stressed, and increasingly at risk of attack. Worse, the centralization and increased interdependence of these grids mean the risk for large-scale failure has never been greater.

If we don't act quickly, the next time the lights go out, they may not turn on again.

Full transcript available

Chapters

  • 00:00 Preshow
  • 00:45 What is the Grid?
  • 01:58 Some History
  • 03:53 The Grid Today
  • 05:27 Foliage
  • 07:45 Renewable: Difficulties
  • 09:40 Renewables: Subsidies
  • 12:06 Energy Storage
  • 14:37 Transformers: Ageing
  • 16:25 Transformers: Raw Materials
  • 17:19 Transformers: Lead Time
  • 19:53 Critical Substations
  • 21:04 Physical Threats
  • 21:29 Physical Threats: Liberty
  • 22:54 Physical Threats: Metcalf
  • 27:33 Transformers: Spares in Reserves?
  • 29:47 Cyber Threats
  • 31:42 Ukraine Cyber Attack
  • 35:09 Incentives for a Cyber Attack
  • 38:21 How Will War Begin?
  • 39:56 What happens when the Lights go Off?
  • 42:15 Electromagnetic Pulse
  • 43:06 Solar Threat
  • 44:04 Carington Event
  • 46:28 1989 Geomagnetic Storm
  • 48:04 Bureaucracy
  • 48:29 What Can we Do?
  • 55:21 Wrap up

Sources

@Misc{nasa_2018,
author    = {NASA},
title     = {Geomagnetic Field Perturbations},
month     = {Mar},
year      = {2018},
journal   = {Geomagnetic Field Perturbations},
publisher = {NASA},
url       = {https://iswa.gsfc.nasa.gov/IswaSystemWebApp/index.jsp?i_1=601&l_1=339&t_1=755&w_1=640&h_1=410&s_1=0_0_10_3&i_2=592&l_2=25&t_2=336&w_2=640&h_2=410&s_2=0_0_10_3&i_3=593&l_3=670&t_3=335&w_3=640&h_3=410&s_3=0_0_10_3&i_4=388&l_4=265&t_4=1175&w_4=800&h_4=400&s_4=0!3!0!BOU.E_x!BOU.E_y!},
}


@Misc{maloney_2017,
author  = {Maloney, Dan},
title   = {Lights Out in Québec: The 1989 Geomagnetic Storm},
month   = {Aug},
year    = {2017},
journal = {Hackaday},
url     = {https://hackaday.com/2017/04/10/lights-out-in-quebec-the-1989-geomagnetic-storm/},
}


@Article{asce,
author  = {ASCE},
title   = {Infrastructure Report Card},
journal = {ASCE Infrastructure Report Card},
year    = {2017},
url     = {https://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Energy-Final.pdf},
}


@Article{glenn_sterbentz_wright_2016,
author  = {Glenn, Colleen and Sterbentz, Dane and Wright, Aaron},
title   = {Cyber Threat and Vulnerability Analysis of the U.S. Electric Sector},
journal = {Mission Support Center Analysis Report},
year    = {2016},
month   = {Aug},
doi     = {10.2172/1337873},
}


@Misc{dunietz_2017,
author  = {Dunietz, Jesse},
title   = {Is the Power Grid Getting More Vulnerable to Cyber Attacks?},
month   = {Aug},
year    = {2017},
journal = {Scientific American},
url     = {https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-the-power-grid-getting-more-vulnerable-to-cyber-attacks/},
}


@Article{executiveofficeofthepresident_2013,
author  = {Executive Office of the President},
title   = {Economic Benefits of Increasing Electric Grid Resilience to Weather Outages},
journal = {Executive Office of the President},
year    = {2013},
url     = {https://energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2013/08/f2/Grid%20Resiliency%20Report_FINAL.pdf},
}


@Misc{rhodes_2018,
author  = {Rhodes, Joshua D},
title   = {The old, dirty, creaky US electric grid would cost $5 trillion to replace. Where should infrastructure spending go?},
month   = {Feb},
year    = {2018},
journal = {The Conversation},
url     = {https://theconversation.com/the-old-dirty-creaky-us-electric-grid-would-cost-5-trillion-to-replace-where-should-infrastructure-spending-go-68290},
}


@Misc{galbraith_2011,
author    = {Galbraith, Kate},
title     = {Texplainer: Why Does Texas Have Its Own Power Grid?},
month     = {Feb},
year      = {2011},
journal   = {The Texas Tribune},
publisher = {Texas Tribune},
url       = {https://www.texastribune.org/2011/02/08/texplainer-why-does-texas-have-its-own-power-grid/},
}


@Misc{energy.gov_2014,
author  = {Energy.gov},
title   = {Top 9 Things You Didn't Know About America's Power Grid},
year    = {2014},
journal = {Energy.gov},
url     = {https://energy.gov/articles/top-9-things-you-didnt-know-about-americas-power-grid},
}


@Misc{bell_philips_2008,
author    = {Bell, Trudy E and Philips, Tony},
title     = {A Super Solar Flare},
month     = {May},
year      = {2008},
journal   = {NASA},
publisher = {NASA},
url       = {https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2008/06may_carringtonflare},
}


@Misc{taggert_2013,
author  = {Taggert, Adam},
title   = {NASA: Our Technology-Dependent Lifestyle is Vulnerable to Solar Flares},
month   = {Aug},
year    = {2013},
journal = {Peak Prosperity},
url     = {https://www.peakprosperity.com/podcast/82542/nasa-our-technology-dependent-lifestyle-vulnerable-solar-flares},
}


@Article{riley_2012,
author  = {Riley, Pete},
title   = {On the probability of occurrence of extreme space weather events},
journal = {Space Weather},
year    = {2012},
volume  = {10},
number  = {2},
doi     = {10.1029/2011sw000734},
url     = {http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2011SW000734/abstract},
}


@Article{melott_thomas_2012,
author  = {Melott, Adrian L. and Thomas, Brian C.},
title   = {Causes of an ad 774–775 14C increase},
journal = {Nature},
year    = {2012},
volume  = {491},
number  = {7426},
doi     = {10.1038/nature11695},
url     = {https://www.nature.com/articles/nature11695.epdf?referrer_access_token=3ffVCoZNue1Q-zOiMjWEk9RgN0jAjWel9jnR3ZoTv0OLZgXwM49VfPpDj05H7TdEVnFTSwaF_5eDlOX8wtB5Oy_YjL8cAkeGRQtcHWYcj1QA5rrdneBopdCaLGSIMDWBNc_K45Cix35_sxW8-RJM0XMA4ciSQpX3lgLkui4Elp3DO5BCyPQ_Ldyb3nsXY_zziaout2soXVqxxBPaKR__a4Nh_ZkKPaI2hY7pGf_HOT9xtLEFjg4Wniqd8leEUAxindQm76j0oJXNj89UZ-dERA%3D%3D&tracking_referrer=blogs.nature.com},
}


@Article{doe_2014,
author  = {DoE},
title   = {Large Power Transformers and the US Electric Grid},
journal = {Infrastructure Security and Energy Restoration Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability U.S. Department of Energy},
year    = {2014},
month   = {Apr},
url     = {https://energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2014/04/f15/LPTStudyUpdate-040914.pdf},
}


@Article{efi_2015,
author  = {EFI},
title   = {Comments on a National Power Transformer Reserve Program},
journal = {EEI APPA NRECA Submission},
year    = {2015},
month   = {Aug},
url     = {https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2015/09/f26/EEI-APPA-NRECA_Submission_RFI_Transformer%20Reserve.PDF},
}


@Misc{mitssunaga_2018,
author  = {Mitssunaga, Jorge},
title   = {Explosion, fire at power plant cause blackout in northern Puerto Rico},
month   = {Feb},
year    = {2018},
journal = {CBS},
}


@Article{graham_pry_2017,
author  = {Graham, William R and Pry, Peter V},
title   = {Empty Threat or Serious Danger},
journal = {Commission to Asess the Threat to the United States From Electromagnetic Pulse (EMP) Attack},
year    = {2017},
month   = {Oct},
url     = {http://docs.house.gov/meetings/HM/HM09/20171012/106467/HHRG-115-HM09-Wstate-PryP-20171012.pdf},
}


@Misc{emerson_2017,
author  = {Emerson, Sarah},
title   = {FEMA Is Preparing for a Solar Superstorm That Would Take Down the Grid},
month   = {Jun},
year    = {2017},
journal = {Motherboard},
url     = {https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/ev473k/fema-is-preparing-for-a-solar-superstorm-that-would-take-down-the-grid},
}


@Article{lafleur_2017,
author  = {LaFleur, Cheryl},
title   = {Grid Reliability Commission},
journal = {FERC Before the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources},
year    = {2017},
month   = {May},
url     = {https://www.ferc.gov/CalendarFiles/20170504093843-LaFleur-05-04-2017.pdf},
}


@Article{barnes_tesche_vance_1992,
author  = {Barnes, P.r. and Tesche, F.m. and Vance, E.f.},
title   = {Mitigation of magnetohydrodynamic electromagnetic pulse (MHD-EMP) effects from commerical electric power systems},
journal = {Oak Ridge National Lab},
year    = {1992},
month   = {Jan},
doi     = {10.2172/5034615},
}


@Article{horton_2017,
author  = {Horton, R},
title   = {Magnetohydrodynamic Electromagnetic Pulse Assessment of the Continental U.S. Electric Grid: Voltage Stability Analysis},
journal = {Electric Power Research Institute},
year    = {2017},
month   = {Dec},
url     = {https://www.epri.com/#/pages/product/000000003002011969/},
}


@Misc{jergler_2017,
author  = {Jergler, Don},
title   = {Report: Climate Change May Pose Threat to Nation's Electric Grid},
month   = {Jul},
year    = {2017},
journal = {Insurance Journal},
url     = {https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2017/07/27/459196.htm},
}


@Misc{gara_2014,
author    = {Gara, Tom},
title     = {Q\&A: What You Need to Know About Attacks on the U.S. Power Grid},
month     = {Feb},
year      = {2014},
journal   = {The Wall Street Journal},
publisher = {Dow Jones \& Company},
url       = {https://blogs.wsj.com/corporate-intelligence/2014/02/05/qa-what-you-need-to-know-about-attacks-on-the-u-s-power-grid/},
}


@Misc{reilly_2015,
author    = {Reilly, Steve},
title     = {Bracing for a big power grid attack: One is too many},
month     = {Mar},
year      = {2015},
journal   = {USA Today},
publisher = {Gannett Satellite Information Network},
url       = {https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2015/03/24/power-grid-physical-and-cyber-attacks-concern-security-experts/24892471/},
}


@Misc{poulsen_2017,
author    = {Poulsen, Kevin},
title     = {U.S. Power Companies Warned 'Nightmare' Cyber Weapon Already Causing Blackouts},
month     = {Jun},
year      = {2017},
journal   = {The Daily Beast},
publisher = {The Daily Beast Company},
url       = {https://www.thedailybeast.com/newly-discovered-nightmare-cyber-weapon-is-already-causing-blackouts},
}


@Misc{serrano_halper_2014,
author    = {Serrano, Richard A and Halper, Evan},
title     = {Sophisticated but low-tech power grid attack baffles authorities},
month     = {Feb},
year      = {2014},
journal   = {Los Angeles Times},
publisher = {Los Angeles Times},
url       = {http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-grid-attack-20140211-story.html},
}


@Book{bakke_2017,
title     = {The grid: the fraying wires between Americans and our energy future},
publisher = {Bloomsbury Publishing Plc},
year      = {2017},
author    = {Bakke, Gretchen Anna.},
place     = {New York, NY},
}


@Misc{bedard_2015,
author    = {Bedard, Paul},
title     = {DOE warns 'modern life' threatened by terror, climate threats to electric grid},
month     = {Apr},
year      = {2015},
journal   = {Washington Examiner},
publisher = {Washington Examiner},
url       = {http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/doe-warns-modern-life-threatened-by-terror-climate-threats-to-electric-grid/article/2563360},
}


@Misc{crawford_2014,
author    = {Crawford, Jamie},
title     = {Govt: China could take down U.S. power grid - CNNPolitics},
month     = {Nov},
year      = {2014},
journal   = {CNN},
publisher = {Cable News Network},
url       = {https://www.cnn.com/2014/11/20/politics/nsa-china-power-grid/index.html},
}


@Misc{smith_2016,
author    = {Smith, Rebecca},
title     = {How America Could Go Dark},
month     = {Jul},
year      = {2016},
journal   = {The Wall Street Journal},
publisher = {Dow Jones \& Company},
url       = {https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-america-could-go-dark-1468423254},
}


@Misc{walton_2015,
author  = {Walton, Robert},
title   = {DOE may stockpile large transformers to thwart grid threats},
month   = {Mar},
year    = {2015},
journal = {Utility Dive},
url     = {https://www.utilitydive.com/news/doe-may-stockpile-large-transformers-to-thwart-grid-threats/374703/},
}


@Misc{doan_2018,
author    = {Doan, Lynn},
title     = {Wall Street Has a $1.7 Billion Bet on the Rising Risk of Grid Attacks},
month     = {Jan},
year      = {2018},
journal   = {Bloomberg.com},
publisher = {Bloomberg},
url       = {https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-01-17/wall-street-s-1-7-billion-bet-on-rising-risk-of-grid-attacks},
}


@Misc{greenberg_2017,
author    = {Greenberg, Andy},
title     = {Hackers Gain Direct Access to US Power Grid Controls},
month     = {Sep},
year      = {2017},
journal   = {Wired},
publisher = {Conde Nast},
url       = {https://www.wired.com/story/hackers-gain-switch-flipping-access-to-us-power-systems/},
}


@Article{economist_2017,
author  = {Economist},
title   = {A Flash in the Sky; If an Electromagnetic Pulse Took Down Americas Electricity Grid},
journal = {The Economist (US)},
year    = {2017},
month   = {Jul},
}


@Misc{brannen_2017,
author    = {Brannen, Peter},
title     = {This is how your world could end},
month     = {Sep},
year      = {2017},
journal   = {The Observer},
publisher = {Guardian News and Media},
url       = {https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/sep/09/this-is-how-your-world-could-end-climate-change-global-warming},
}


@Misc{polson_2018,
author    = {Polson, Jim},
title     = {America's Power Grid Is Showing Signs of Strain During Brutal Cold},
month     = {Jan},
year      = {2018},
journal   = {Bloomberg.com},
publisher = {Bloomberg},
url       = {https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-01-02/america-s-power-grid-showing-signs-of-strain-amid-brutal-cold},
}


@Misc{malik_2017,
author    = {Malik, Naureen S},
title     = {Can America's Power Grid Survive an Electromagnetic Attack?},
month     = {Dec},
year      = {2017},
journal   = {Bloomberg.com},
publisher = {Bloomberg},
url       = {https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-12-22/hardening-power-grids-for-nuclear-and-emp-attacks-by-north-korea},
}


@Misc{tweed_2014,
author    = {Tweed, Katherine},
title     = {Attack on Nine Substations Could Take Down U.S. Grid},
month     = {Mar},
year      = {2014},
journal   = {IEEE Spectrum: Technology, Engineering, and Science News},
publisher = {IEEE Spectrum},
url       = {https://spectrum.ieee.org/energywise/energy/the-smarter-grid/attack-on-nine-substations-could-take-down-us-grid},
}
Published 01-03-2018 03:01